Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Bad Relationships

Over the past few weeks, I've seen a lot of posts around the Internet about people in bad relationships, or unhealthy relationships, or relationships that are OK but that just aren't making them happy.

And then I saw this: 


And I went, Wa-hey, that looks familiar. 

Why? Because my first serious relationship was, to sum it up nicely, not a very healthy one.

We met when I was seventeen (OH how stupid I was at seventeen!) and started dating when I was eighteen. We were together for 3 months, tried to be in an "open" relationship for 3 months after that (at my suggestion, because OH how stupid I was at eighteen!) then got back into a "closed" relationship for 4 months, after which I sort-of-but-not-really-dumped him. 

We spent the next 9 months breaking up. 

Hence the "sort-of-but-not-really". 

It was a very intense, tumultuous relationship that consumed both of us at the start and, as time went on, seemed to swallow only me. And I'm not going to lie, I was also responsible for our relationship's decay. But when you're dating someone you consider your best friend, when they're the first person you've ever really loved, it's very hard to extricate yourself. Like, very hard. Extremely hard. Nearly a year's worth of disentangling kind of hard. 

I'd like to tell you that the key to realizing the relationship wasn't good for me was an enlightening moment filled with lots of introspection and intelligent self-diagnosis, but, ah. Well. It wasn't. 

The thing that made me go, "OK, I've had enough," was...a L'Oréal commercial. 

I kid you not. 

You know how their commercials always say, "Because you're worth it?" 

I was watching one one day, angsting over my tangled mess of a relationship, and suddenly went, "You know what? I am. I am worth it, L'Oréal." 

And then, though I'd been avoiding watching He's Just Not That Into You (because I knew what it was going to tell me), I watched the movie. And then I bought the book. I read it cover to cover, and even though it kind of sucked to read (because obviously, who wants to hear over and over that the person you love doesn't love you back?) it was also incredibly, incredibly freeing. 

The thing that made it hardest to leave my ex was that we had no closure. Ever heard "You Keep Me Hanging On?" by the Supremes? Well, if not, take a second and here you go: 


"You Keep Me Hanging On"
The Supremes

That song was basically where I lived (emotionally speaking, of course). 

He's Just Not That Into You gave me the closure I needed to finally, completely end my relationship with my ex. I'd needed to hear, "I don't love you, I don't care about you, and I don't want to be with you now or ever," and that book finally gave that to me. It hurt like hell, of course, but it, to quote the Supremes, set me free. I didn't have to wait for him anymore.

At long last, I was allowed to leave.

(And also? It made me stop feeling crazy. It made me stop feeling like the problem, like I was fundamentally flawed. It recounted situations that were incredibly familiar, and cleanly and concisely laid out how the guy was being a jerk and I was being foolish enough to think he wasn't.) 

That book, dumb as it sounds, helped me get out of a bad relationship and stay out of it. Every time I tried to reason myself back into the relationship, the book was like, "Seriously? This guy is not good for you. You best stop yo'self." And I did, because as much as breaking up for good sucked (and ohhhh dear Lord did it suck) I knew that continuing that relationship would hurt more. 

If you're trying to get out of a relationship that isn't right for you, this is probably going to sound familiar: 
  • You feel like you are literally cutting your heart out of your chest. There is physical pain. No, I am not making this up. 
  • You cry. A lot. Sometimes you schedule your crying so that your roommates are less likely to hear you (like shower time!) or you pick spots that you hope might possibly muffle you (wa-hey, sobbin' in the closet!) or you stuff mouthfuls of pillow into your face in an attempt to stifle the sound of you losing control of yourself completely.
  • You despair, because even though losing this person hurts like your soul is in flames, being with this person feels like someone is shaving off little bits of you one day at a time. And both of those things are too painful to deal with.
There are more, obviously. Maybe your mutual friends turn out to be not-so-mutual and you're suddenly on your own. Maybe everything reminds you of them, so nothing is comforting. Maybe you get kind of useless at school (I usually do the opposite and work much harder than I should when I'm sad.) Maybe you decide to completely reinvent yourself. I don't know, this is your story. 

But if being in your relationship is making you sad more than it's making you happy, and if they're making you feel bad about yourself, and if you feel like everything is your fault but you can't understand why, and if the things they tell you sound illogical but when they say them you can't figure out the inconsistency, and if you cry because of them on a regular basis, and if you start to forget what you actually like, and if you feel like everything you do and are is wrong and try to change yourself but fail because it seriously isn't you, it's them (but you don't know this at the time) then babe, listen.

They're just not that into you. 

But that's okay, because there's someone out there who is going to be totally, mind-numbingly, brilliantly into you. It doesn't seem like it - I know, I've been there - but there is. My current relationship is light years better than my last. It is, in fact, so much nicer that every time I look back on my last relationship I wonder why on Earth I was ever sad that it ended. 

What I'm saying is, let go of things that hurt you. Even if the letting go hurts. And move on to something better. 

My Break-Up Playlist: 

"Giving Up" - Ingrid Michaelson
"Eet" - Regina Spektor
"It Ain't Me, Babe" - Bob Dylan
"Don't Think Twice, It's All Right" - Peter, Paul and Mary
"For No One" - The Beatles
"Creep" - Radiohead
"Oh! Darling" - The Beatles
"Parting Gift" - Fiona Apple
"Colorblind" - Counting Crows
"Hallelujah" - Jeff Buckley
"The Blower's Daughter" - Damien Rice
"I Have Stopped Thinking About You" - Tango Apple Tango
"Glass" - Ingrid Michaelson
"Keep Breathing" - Ingrid Michaelson
"A Lack of Color" - Death Cab for Cutie
"Matinee" - Hurts to Purr
"Lonelily" - Damien Rice
"Look What You've Done" - Jet
"Ruin My Day" - Jon Brion
"All God's Angels" - Kate Rusby
"Stardust Motel" - Andrew Norsworthy
"Shoes" - Chris Volpe
"Breakeven" - The Script

(There are more, but that should get you started.) 

52 comments:

  1. You're fab, stay fierce.

    ReplyDelete
  2. We're silly, sometimes. I often have to remind myself when things aren't making me happy. This is silly!

    Well said. :]

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for this. In June, I got out of an 8-week (yes, 8-week) relationship that had its basis in about 18 months of friendship, flirtation and being lead on. I'm 25 and it was the first time I'd dated anyone. And, even though our time as a couple was brief, the entire thing has been complicated and messy and hurtful.

    And I feel totally stupid. And don't know if I can ever do this ever again.

    A lot of the emotions you described are spot-on with what I've felt over the last few weeks. I get the pain (I have been known to describe it as, "I feel like someone is taking my heart and running it over a cheese grater."), I still cry sometimes and I still don't know if I can ever subject myself to a relationship again. This one was so weirdly vague and lacking direction...I honestly wonder if one or both of us was more in love with a projected idea rather than with each other.

    All I really know to do is trust the Lord with where I am, know that things can get better and learn from what has happened. I have learned a lot about myself through this entire process, and even though I'm a bit frustrated at knowing that I still feel some hurt 3 months after an 8-week relationship, it has been, in a strange way, worth it.

    I know that I can have standards and expectations without being unreasonable. I know that my affections are worth more than vague intentions and unconvincing flattering words. And I know that I do have value in the Lord.

    Thanks again for this entry. I enjoyed reading it and could relate to so much of it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ending relationships is incredibly difficult. I felt stupid, too, and I didn't want to ever date anyone ever again. It hurts too badly!

      But I really do think that for every bad relationship you have, there's a good one out there waiting for you. You've just got to pick yourself up, put yourself back together, and try again.

      Delete
    2. I will eventually. I'm much close to that that I was two months ago...one month ago...two weeks ago... so that's good :).

      We're still friendly-ish. But the more I realize how ridiculous the relationship was, the less I want to even acknowledge that it happened. My pastor (rightly) told me today that I don't just get to delete the entire experience...I have to learn and move on. So, I'm trying to do that without making the entire thing constantly awkward (The Boy in Question also works with me and we go to the same very-small church, so there is no lack of opportunity for awkwardness).

      Delete
  4. The inforgraphic for this post really upsets me because I have thought each one of those things at least once in my relationship. I don't think them all of the time, but when we are fighting all of these have passed through my mind. But I am so happy now and haven't thought these things in a long time, should I still be with him? Is the bad history enough to warrant ending the current? Blah, stream of consciousness comment is streamy and cousciousnessy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't know your situation, so I don't know! The things in the drawing were thoughts I had after ending my bad relationship. I was still in bad-relationship- mode, so I was scared of doing things "wrong" in my new relationship. That's how I related to it.

      Delete
  5. I was in a very abusive relationship with someone for almost two years and I just spent almost 11 months breaking up with him. For 10 months of those 11 he had a new girlfriend already, starting the same cycle with her. This post almost made me cry because for some reason I always thought this didn't happen to other "normal" people. Thank you so much :')

    ReplyDelete
  6. Love your post. I can definitely relate. I was feeling blue earlier and as i was reading your post it reminded me that there WILL be better things to come. Maybe not soon, but there is a reason the past happened the way it happened. LOL "Creep" by Radiohead seems to be a lot of people's break-up song...including mine xD.

    ReplyDelete
  7. It's nice to hear from someone I can relate to who's been there and gotten out of it. I was in a bad relationship for about 5 months, and I finally realized that I wasn't being appreciated, or treated like I should have been treated. It was only when I took the blinders off that I realized how I was being mistreated.

    Now, I'm in a much healthier and wonderful relationship. And I'm glad you are too. Isn't it nice to know you're worth it? :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. This may be just me but I feel what the drawing says about everyone I know... Except for the love bits... They're just people I know... Still thanks for sharing makes me think twice about what's going on =).

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love break-up playlists! I've been with my current boyfriend for almost 3 years and it's honestly the best relationship I've ever been in. I look back at all my other relationships and heartbreaks and I honestly don't understand what planet I was on. But god I love a good break-up song.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Wow, this was amazing! I know lots of people must have found that book helpful or it wouldn't be a bestseller, but I felt kind of silly reading it, and yet everything made so much sense. I was living with my boyfriend of three years at the time and it really helped me when our relationship ended. I read it while I packed up all my stuff, and I read it again when I got my own apartment, just to make sure I wouldn't entangle myself with him again :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I just want to say that is a BEAUTIFUL playlist. :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Everything you said, and everything in the graphic, really fits the current "on-off" relationship of a friend of mine. So much so that I actually want to send her the link to this post... but her relationship problems have been the source of many sour points in our friendship, mainly because she's aware that she's in an emotionally abusive relationship but doesn't want to get out of it because she's convinced that he's "the one" as they've been together, on and off, for 5 years. Also her boyfriend hates her friends (and we hate him just as well, this mutual dislike is no secret to anyone). I'm pretty sure many lines have been crossed just trying to define where concern ends and intrusiveness begins.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This is a fantastic post :) All of my friends have only had very snappy break-ups, so I've always felt like the only one who has been through a massive, prolonged break-up with your best friend where your heart literally felt like it was being ripped from its chest. Good to know I'm not alone, and your style of writing is really fantastic!

    ReplyDelete
  14. awesome post. i was in love with him for 3 years, then we dated 2 months, he broke up with me 8 months ago and it still hurts me

    ReplyDelete
  15. Well done. I'm glad you were able to move on from a dark time and step into a brighter one. I'm sure it was hard, things like this always are (hah, let me not pretend i have experience in this field). But it's beautiful to see that you finally realized how strong you are :)

    ReplyDelete
  16. Nice post :) Now, I demand the playlist on your channel (it wouldn't be fair if I or somebody else created it)!

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'd like to recommend the song Red Cape by Priscilla Ahn.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I love Priscilla Ahn! I also recommend:

      "This Too Shall Pass" by OK Go, and
      "Foundations" by Kate Nash.

      Excellent post, Bryarly! Perhaps you should make a post on what to do during the inbetween singledom? I feel like there's a lot to be said on that as well, and I'd love to hear your words of wisdom

      Delete
    2. I thought this was normal.
      I feel quite disheartened now.

      Either way, I guess I'm glad I read this. I don't know why. I always hope that things will get better one day, but I guess that's a bit of wishful thinking.

      Thanks for saying what nobody else bothers to talk about.

      Delete
  18. This is an excellent post. thanks for it.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Wow, this was great... I've been in an abuse relationship for 2/3 years but I've never looked at it like that. I never saw that the things he did were abusive, I only saw the mistakes that I made. It was my fault, not his. I started seeing things differently when I got therapy, 2 years after the relationship ended. I'm having a really hard time letting go of him, or this vague idea of him that I've made up in my mind. I miss him, I just want to talk to him, want him to give me a hug. But I'm slowly starting to realize that that will never happen, that I need to let go.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Aww.. Iv never been in a relationship but this was a nice read and hey, I have a few songs to listen to now lol.. You’re with Charlie right? I found about you throughh charlie’s video and I'm super thrilled with you and Charlie being together.! You’re such a cute couple.. :D Woo hoo

    ReplyDelete
  21. What's an undouchy way of sending this blog post to my sister? She just got out of a bad relationship and is getting back into it without telling anyone. I feel like this post would help but I don't know how to show it to her without her getting super pissed at me.

    ReplyDelete
  22. just hoping that your current relationship never goes that way and that God does keep you two together and allows your hearts to understand true love that comes with no hurt.

    ReplyDelete
  23. What a great post. I wish that everyone in a bad relationship can see this and wake up. I was in a bad relationship when I first started college. I didn't realize the relationship was bad until I met my now husband. When we met and started hanging out and he was treating me a million times better than my "boyfriend" I knew something had to change. I broke up with him and started dating my husband. A few months later, I talked to that first guy, and I ended up learning that I was "the other woman." After learning that, I was really happy I got out of that relationship when I did.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Great job! It really brought back some memories. I remember I was trying to get over a relationship and my friends kinda forced me to read that book. Once I picked it up I could not put it down. I was up all night with a flashlight just reading that book. It really helped me feel better about myself and it gave myself closure.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Thank you so much for this post, Bryarly :) I was in an unhealthy relationship for many months and no one seemed to understand the actual physical pain I was in during and after the relationship. Most just thought I was being dramatic. I am so glad that someone else knows exactly what I was going through.

    ReplyDelete
  26. this is such a wonderful blog entry!

    ReplyDelete
  27. This is so amazing, you are amazing. I think everyone can connect to this. And this can be so helpfull if you are in a situation like this. THANK YOU SO MUCH!!
    I am really happy you found someone you can be yourself with and who loves you for who you are. I haven't found that one person yet, but I know I will, some day.
    I wish you all the best in your relationship and hope it will keep making you happy.

    ReplyDelete
  28. The very first person I've ever been in love with was my best friend (yeah, cliché, I know). After a year of chasing him, we finally get together but, oh dear Lord, it was so bad, so incredibly ridiculously bad. He told me we should keep our relationship secret because it was *so special and private*. And I, as the idiotic human being I was at 14, I believed him. But then things went worse, because he doesn't want to go out with me in public or kiss me or even hold my hand. He as good as felt ashamed to be my boyfriend because - at the time - I was nerdy, chubby and not very attractive. (Let's face it: I was considered a loser). Anyway, I didn't want to break up with him because 1) I thought no one would ever want me besides him and 2) I loved him too much. So I cried, oh boy if I cried, and felt like the ugliest, most hideous girl on the planet. I was drowning into an endless spiral of sadness, shame and regret. I was depressed and miserable and one day I thought: "that's not how a relationship should make you feel" so I broke up with him. It was the most painful thing I've ever done. He wasn't cruel though, oh no, he simply didn't care and few days later he started dating another girl. He was my very first love and he made me feel like I didn't worth anything, like I didn't deserve anything. Now, even if my friends and family tell me I'm pretty and smart and special, I simply don't believe them and keep pulling away all the boys who I suspect would fancy me. I don't want to be hurt anymore. But, oh my, I want to fall in love *so badly*.

    ReplyDelete
  29. My mum is in a relationship like that and has been for a good 5 years. I don't know what to do anymore. It's gotten to the point were I feel like I'm drifting away from her and I don't trust her and she's changed who she is and I want to run away. Every time we -myself and my siblings- try to say something to her about it she either gets offended and yells at us or she says she'll leave him but of course she never does. I need her to leave him because I feel like I'm losing my mum and I'm only 14 going on 15 and I need her more than ever now. I just want my mum back. I don't know if you could give me any advice but please try, I need your help, Bryarly.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Brilliant post. One of my sisters is in this kind of relationship.

    ReplyDelete
  31. "But that's okay, because there's someone out there who is going to be totally, mind-numbingly, brilliantly into you" - I've always found it hard to believe this, that someone will truly be into me. But since you say so and you have a very trustworthy face, I'll believe you.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Another really great break-up song is 'Fuck Was I' by Jenny Owen Youngs.

    A dysfunctional relationship is an indication that you are dysfunctional just as much as your partner. Because if you have outgrown that level of dysfunction, you would have left already. We have to be functional to accept healthy, positive love. Even if we find someone who is willing to give us that kind of love while we are dysfunctional, we will sabotage it. Relationships offer the opportunity to grow into a more functional person capable of loving and being loved.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I can't say that I know the feeling, my relationship is awful, etc. because I'm a bit too young. But I did love this post, and I'm glad you got over him. Good for you! I'm also happy that your in a good relationship now, which is what really matters.
    Laura Marie
    (Oh, and by the way, I love that movie. Ginnifer Goodwin is the best.)

    ReplyDelete
  34. I thank you wholeheartedly for this :) You are awesome... keep up the good blogging. I got out of a long long long relationship in a terrible way with my closest childhood friend... It's been over a year, and still struggling to maintain my composure in life. Thanks for the perspective. Very appreciated :)

    ReplyDelete
  35. Wonderful post Bryarly, thank you so much for your honesty and advice. I had a really difficult relationship which sort-of-but-never-really ended until last year when just cut the chords. It was extremely painful but it really did make my life a lot better. Anyway, a great post.

    ReplyDelete
  36. To me it wasn't about hoping for someone better. I needed to understand that i might or might not find love after the breakup, and that i would be ok afterwards (hell-better!) because i had me, and that was enough and wonderful and full of possibilities. So in a sense it was about someone new and better, me. That was kinda my path, and even if im not a very productive person like i want (?-i wonder if i do want this why don't i) i am much more appreciative of myself, healthier.

    ReplyDelete
  37. This is something I struggled with, as well, through a four year relationship. We were so serious that we were engaged for two years of it. Anyway, I really appreciate the honesty (I know for a fact how difficult it can be to discuss things like that), and I think the advice you give is spot-on.

    ReplyDelete
  38. What a wonderful post. Bryarly, you truly are an inspiration. And I totally agree about "A Lack of Color".

    ReplyDelete
  39. I recently ended a relationship with my boyfriend of 4 years, and that was incredible difficult. It was so complicated as I still loved him but he no longer loved me... And also we were in a nearly fatal car accident together just over a year ago.
    It was so difficult because my boyfriend would have strung me alone for a year if I'd let him, just having the label and having me do things for him while I was receiving nothing but emotional toil.
    Finally, I demanded to know whether he was interested in continuing the relationship for real or if we were done in his eyes. He said we were done.
    Getting over him has sucked, as he's already sleeping with someone else, but overall I've realized I have the opportunity to hang out with so many more awesome people now that I don't feel the need to cling to him.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Relationship Tips by NewarkThe quality of information that you are providing is simply marvelous.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Look for Bharat Softech Here
    I have been getting a lot of useful and informative material in your website.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Dear Bryarly,
    *sighs deeply, and freely*. Thank you for sharing your insight with your experience. I didn't see it. "I'm not that girl! I am SO not that girl." But I am, or, was. I didn't want to be the girl that has love for someone who's affection (or lack thereof) is poisonous, but I was. I started reading your list of symptoms, and it cut. "That's not healthy" thought I. I didn't think it was that way, because it set in so subtlety. So, thank you! You ripped the glasses I was wearing (that were trying so hard to be rose-colored that they tried to only see rose-colored things), and showed me a bit of reality. (:

    ReplyDelete
  43. Just reading this helped me realize something I've been waiting to figure out for months.

    I will be okay.

    I'm at the end of the seventh month after my first break up ever, with a guy I thought was the love of my life, who left me and never gave me any reason or closure or anything, and he broke up with me the morning I was leaving for a school trip for three days. I spent the trip miserable and wasted basically my entire summer wondering what I did wrong and doing absolutely nothing interesting or productive or useful. I did a show recently, and my cast and the friends I made from that show have helped me immensely, but something about hearing all this from you made it really click.

    2013 is going to be a great year. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete

Got some thoughts? Wanna share 'em? Go for it!